Is Behavior Therapy or Medication more effective in treating Children with ADHD?

Posted on February 22, 2014

Med­ica­tion treat­ment and behav­ior ther­apy are both con­sid­ered effec­tive treat­ments for ADHD; the com­bi­na­tion of these treat­ments is gen­er­ally regarded as an ideal approach for many chil­dren. How­ever, in the Mul­ti­modal Treat­ment Study of ADHD (MTA Study), the largest ADHD treat­ment study ever con­ducted, the ben­e­fit of com­bined treat­ment rel­a­tive to med­ica­tion treat­ment alone — while sig­nif­i­cant for some out­come mea­sures — was not espe­cially robust. This has led some pro­fes­sion­als to ques­tion whether behav­ior ther­apy is nec­es­sary when a child is being effec­tively treated with med­ica­tion, i.e., will behav­ior ther­apy make a suf­fi­cient dif­fer­ent to be worth­while?

A study recently pub­lished online in the Jour­nal of Abnor­mal Child Psy­chol­ogy [Pel­ham et al., (2014). A dose-ranging study of behav­ioral and phar­ma­co­log­i­cal treat­ment in social set­tings for chil­dren with ADHD, DOI 10,1007/s10802-013‑9843-8 ] takes a care­ful look at this impor­tant issue. Par­tic­i­pants were 48 5–12 year-old chil­dren with ADHD who were par­tic­i­pat­ing in an inten­sive sum­mer treat­ment pro­gram (STP). The STP ran for 9 hours/day and lasted 9 weeks. Chil­dren spent 2 hours each day in aca­d­e­mic activ­i­ties and the rest of each day in group recre­ational activ­i­ties sim­i­lar to a reg­u­lar sum­mer day camp.

The really inter­est­ing find­ings from this study con­cern the com­bi­na­tion of med­ica­tion and behav­ioral treat­ment. On vir­tu­ally all mea­sures, adding high inten­sity behav­ior man­age­ment to the low­est med­ica­tion dose of med­ica­tion yielded com­pa­ra­ble improve­ments to those pro­duced by the high dose med­ica­tion alone.

Click on the link below to read the full article.

Category(s):Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

Source material from Sharp Brains

Mental Health News

  • Tempering the Mind

    newsthumbYou always hear the phrase "What doesn't kill you, makes you stronger" being thrown around, but what does it actually refer to? In this article, we ...

  • Waiting Constructively

    newsthumbWe've all had moments where we wait expectantly for some important news to arrive, but sometimes it never does. When all we can do is sit and wait, ...

  • The Family That Dines Together, Stays Together

    newsthumbFor many busy families, getting everyone to sit down at the table together for dinner can seem like an impossible task. However, family dinners can ...